Most people who buy their first generative artwork ask exactly one question: “do I like it?”. It is a legitimate question, but it is the only one they ask — and it is the reason so many digital collections end up as a folder of screenshots with a certificate that certifies nothing.

This is not exclusive to PROJEKTA2 or to any particular artist. It is a structural problem of the market: we buy images, when we should really be buying systems.

“You buy an image. Or you buy a system that generates images. They are different things.” — Alexandre Iglesias

Here are ten concrete questions. Copy them, take them to your next studio visit, or simply run through them before paying for any generative work, whoever made it.

The questions

  1. What exactly am I buying: a closed session, a static export, or a running system?
    These are three completely different things with completely different value implications, and most listings do not say which. A closed session is a specific moment, fixed forever. A static export is a still image with no behaviour. A running system can keep generating new sessions after your purchase — which radically changes what you are acquiring.
  2. Is there a certificate with a cryptographic fingerprint of the source code, not just of the image?
    Signing an image file is trivial and says nothing about the system that produced it. A hash of the source code or of the session does. If the seller can only show you a certificate for the PNG, ask yourself what is really being certified.
  3. Does the work’s behaviour depend on accumulated memory — and can that be demonstrated?
    Many works are sold as “living” or “evolving” without that being verifiable. Ask to see the same interaction repeated at two different moments in the life of the work. If the result is identical, there is no real memory — just an animation with good marketing.
  4. If it is described as irreversible, what exact technical mechanism makes it so?
    “Irreversible” is a word that sounds good and is used far too lightly. Ask about the specific threshold, the state variable, the exact moment at which the change can no longer be undone. If the answer is vague, be suspicious.
  5. What does this work depend on technically to keep running — and what happens if that disappears?
    Browser, graphics library, third-party API, the artist’s own server. Everything has a lifespan. A serious artist has a clear answer to this question. One who has never considered it has probably not thought about the long-term preservation of their own work.
  6. Is there a written migration or emulation plan?
    “I’ll take care of it if something happens” is not enough. Ask for it in writing. It is the difference between a verbal promise and a real obligation.
  7. Does the acquisition involve any recurring payment or dependency on a service that could be discontinued?
    A hidden subscription turns what you think is yours into something you lose if you stop paying. This should be declared explicitly, not discovered six months later.
  8. Is the chain of provenance consistent and available in full?
    Not just the last transaction — the whole chain, from the artist to you. If there are gaps, ask why.
  9. If the system keeps evolving, are you acquiring its current state or a fixed snapshot?
    This determines what a future buyer will be able to buy from you. It is one of the most overlooked questions — and one of those that protects the most value in the long term.
  10. Has the artist disclosed whether the result shown was selected from multiple runs, and by what criteria?
    Curatorial selection is not dishonest — it is common and often necessary. What matters is that it is declared. An artist who explains it transparently is being honest about their own process.
None of these questions requires technical training. They simply require treating the acquisition of generative art with the same rigour as any other decision of value: ask before you pay, not after.
◆ IMAGE / VIDEO A due diligence session
The moment to ask the right questions

If you would like a printable version of this checklist, with space to note the artist’s answers, it is part of the Collector’s Kit included in the Structural Intelligencecourse. You do not need to buy it to use the ten questions above — they are designed to work with any artist, on any platform.