You are about to buy a generative artwork. As proof that the transaction is serious, the seller offers you a certificate of authenticity. It is well designed. It has a seal. It has the word “blockchain” on it somewhere. You sign, you pay, you feel reassured.

In most of the cases I have seen circulating on the market, that certificate certifies one thing only: that an image file exists with an associated hash. It does not certify the system that produced the image. It says nothing about whether the work has memory, whether it is reversible, whether it depends on a server that may disappear next year, or what kind of asset you are really acquiring. In practice, it is beautiful packaging around a question nobody answered.

“I do not think most artists who issue these certificates are trying to deceive anyone. The problem is simpler and more uncomfortable: the generative art market still has no shared vocabulary.” — Alexandre Iglesias

The problem is not bad faith; it is a lack of vocabulary

The problem is simpler and more uncomfortable: the generative art market still has no shared vocabulary to describe what makes these works different from a painting or a photograph. Without that vocabulary, a certificate ends up copying the structure of a traditional art certificate — author, title, date, signature — applied to an object that behaves in a completely different way.

A painting does not cease to exist if a server goes down. A painting has no memory that can be lost in a migration. A painting cannot technically be one of four different things without the buyer knowing. Generative art can.
◆ IMAGE An incomplete certificate
A typical certificate: beautiful, but it does not certify what matters

What a serious certificate should include (and almost none do)

Five fields that rarely appear in current market practice, and that should be standard:

None of these five fields is hard to write. The reason they almost never appear is not technical; it is that they have not yet become the standard buyers demand.

“The market itself is moving in this direction without anyone forcing it from above: more and more buyers talk about depth and provenance rather than aesthetics alone.” — PROJEKTA2 Studio

This is going to change — probably soon

The market itself is moving in this direction: more and more collections combine digital work with physical elements, more and more buyers talk about depth and provenance rather than aesthetics alone, and there is ever more scrutiny of what it really means to “own” something generated by a system. Sooner or later, that scrutiny reaches certificates.

Artists and collectors who start demanding and issuing certificates with this level of detail now are not indulging in bureaucratic excess — they are simply getting ahead of a standard the market will end up needing anyway.

Would you like a certificate template that covers these five fields? It is part of the Collector’s Kit included in the Structural Intelligencecourse, together with a due diligence checklist and a model set of contract clauses for acquisitions. None of the three documents requires the work in question to be by PROJEKTA2 — they are designed to be used with any artist.

You can download the certificate template and the other resources in the Collector’s Kit included in the course Structural Intelligence.