Open almost any piece of digital art, move around a little, close the tab and open it again. Most of the time everything starts from zero, as if you had never been there. The work saw you, but it does not remember you.
That is not a technical flaw: it is an inherited design decision, usually made without thinking about it. And it is the exact border between a work that reacts and a work that lives. This fragment proposes a simple way to tell them apart and explains, openly, how we apply it on this very website.
Four tests to tell whether a digital work is alive
For years we have used the word “generative” for almost anything that moves on a screen. To separate what is alive from what is decorative, we ask four questions. Anyone can ask them, in front of any work, without knowing how to code.
1. The absence test
Does it keep changing when nobody is looking? If the work only exists while you touch it, it is an instrument, not a system. A living system has its own time: it evolves, erodes or grows even when no one is there. In the glossary we call this autonomy.
2. The memory test
Does what you did a minute ago change what happens now? A reactive work always answers the same gesture in the same way. A work with memory accumulates: the tenth gesture is not worth the same as the first, because the previous nine are still there.
3. The return test
Can you go back to exactly the previous state? If reloading the page fixes everything, nothing you did had consequences. Irreversibility is not an aesthetic whim: it is what turns interaction into an event instead of an endless rehearsal.
4. The witness test
Is there a record of what happened? If an unrepeatable state disappears without a trace, for the rest of the world it never existed. A serious living system leaves a trace that others can see and, ideally, verify.
This website as a laboratory
It would be easy to state these tests and not apply them. That is why projekta2.com is built as a small laboratory where each of them can be checked first-hand.
The logo that keeps the scar
The animated logo on the home page is not a video. It is a system that reacts to your presence: it stirs when the cursor gets close and changes tone with the work being shown (gold for Kintsugi, pewter for Wabi, platinum for Yūgen). But it has a detail almost nobody discovers: if you touch it, it keeps the scar. That mark does not disappear as you browse the site; it stays with you for the whole visit. On a phone there is another secret: tilt it and you will see that the logo has weight and squashes against the edge of the screen.
It is a short, deliberately limited memory: one session. It passes the memory test but not the return test, because the next day it is intact again. We designed it that way on purpose, as an example of the difference between remembering and being unable to forget.
The works that never go back, and your trace
The 1/1 works go one step further: while you are looking at them, there is no way back. Every interaction leaves a mark the system itself cannot undo, and the state you produce will never repeat in the same way. Reloading the page does not bring the previous state back: it opens a new instance. That is why the fourth test is decisive, and for it we added something unusual in digital art: the ◎ Your trace button. When you press it, the system captures the exact state your presence produced, gives it a unique number and creates a public address for that moment. You can download it or share it, but that state will never exist in the work again.
The trace contains no personal data: only the image, the work and the date. It is a witness, not a record of who you are.
The plates that never change
The plates that accompany each fragment, including this one, are generated by code. And they are the exact opposite of a living system: the same seed always produces the same image. We include them as an honest contrast. They are algorithmic art, not living systems, and being able to name that difference is the first step to judging a work well.
Why it matters to collectors
The four tests are not just a theoretical curiosity. They determine what you are buying. An animation that restarts is reproducible: its value depends on artificial scarcity. A system with memory and irreversibility is unique by construction: its value lies in the history it accumulates. And the witness test is what makes it possible to prove that history later, at resale, on loan or in an exhibition.
That is why we insist that a certificate for a digital work must include the cryptographic fingerprint of the delivered file, and why we publish free tools to check it. A living work without a witness is a story no one will be able to tell.
Quick questions
Is a generative work always a living work?
No. Most generative works produce variations from rules, but they do not remember or accumulate consequences. Only when a work has autonomy, memory and irreversibility can we call it a living system.
What exactly is “your trace” on PROJEKTA2?
It is an image of the unrepeatable state your interaction produced in a work, with a unique number and a public address you can share. It contains no personal data.
What is the secret of the home page logo?
It reacts to the cursor’s proximity, changes tone with each work and, if you touch it, keeps the scar for the rest of your visit. On a phone, when you tilt it, it squashes elastically against the edge of the screen.